The Tippy is probably your best bet. Pike, unlike Smalleys, don't like the current. So they will lie anywhere they can find out of the current. An undercut bank is a very good spot. Downed trees. River bends. Eddies. Anywhere there is slack in the current. Smalleys, on the other hand, will be in the current.
Thought that might help if you ever get to float it again.
What section did you float?
The upper portions seem to be better for pike.